Showing posts with label evangelical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label evangelical. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Why I am not an Evangelical Christian

Are You Saved? Someone might have asked you this question sometime in your life. If not, someone might still ask you. The fist time I heard this question, I was not sure what was meant by this question. Eventually I understood that by the word salvation he meant the certainty of my soul going to heaven after I die. Once I reach the gates of heaven, the gatekeepers will look for my name in a book called the Book of Life. If my name is found in it, I will be allowed to enter heaven; if not, I will be pushed to hell. It is my responsibility to get my name registered in the book. All I have to do for this is to believe that Jesus Christ died for my sins. The moment I believe this, my name will be entered in the Book of Life, and I will be safe. People can often pinpoint the time at which this event happens. Thus when you are asked "Are you saved?" you should be able to answer like "Yes, I was saved on 10th April, 2005 at 10:35."

The one who asks this question to you is an evangelical Christian. He asks this question because he cares for you. He wants to make sure that you will go to heaven after you die. He does not want you to suffer for eternity in the hellfire. I would acknowledge his care for me, and then politely let him know that I can't agree with his idea of salvation. If he is willing to listen to me, I would explain to him the reason in a way that he understands. This is what I am attempting here-- explain in simple language why I can't agree with an Evangelical Christian's idea of salvation. 

I do this here by presenting three  different worldviews: Other-Worldliness, This-Worldliness, and One-Worldliness. I will explain  how the relationship between God, humanity, and world is viewed in these three worldviews. I will explain why the first two need to be discarded and the third one needs to be accepted.

Other-Worldliness
The evangelical Christians' idea of salvation presupposes a certain view of the world and of human beings. There are two worlds: the physical world and the spiritual world. The physical world is temporary, and is meant to be ultimately destroyed. The spiritual world, which is eternal, exists in two parts: heaven and hell.

A human being is actually the soul that resides within the body.  The body is merely a cover of the soul. The body, which is physical, is temporary, and its existence is limited to the physical world. But the soul, which is spiritual, will exist for eternity either in heaven or in hell.

This view of the world and of human beings is not the original Biblical view. It seems to have originated from the Greeks, and got mixed with the Biblical worldview. Although this view is present in almost all forms of Christianity, it is clearly visible in the evangelical Christianity.  That this view has come from Greeks or that it is not in the original Biblical view is not enough reason for us to discard it. If it were a beneficial view we would welcome it wholeheartedly. Unfortunately it is a harmful view, and so it needs to be discouraged and discarded. This view is often referred to as Other-Worldliness, for it gives undue focus on the other world, and ignores this world. People with this view do not care for the wellbeing of this world; in fact they rejoice at the destruction of this world.

This-Worldliness
This-Worldliness is a view that arises in revolt against Other-Worldliness. This is a naive solution to the problem of Other-Worldliness. It tries to resolve the problem of focusing on the other world by denying the existence of the other world. If there is no other world, how can there be Other-Worldliness? According to This-Worldliness, only the world that is perceptible to our senses exists. Nothing exists beyond what we can perceive. Empiricism, materialism, and atheism are expressions of this view.

One-Worldliness
The two preceding views are extremes. Other-Worldliness focuses on the other world, and This-Worldliness focuses on this world. These two views are always at friction with each other. The solution is to rise above these views, and assume a higher view. I like to call it One-Worldliness. This view affirms that there are not two worlds, but only one world. Only a part of the world is perceptible to our five senses. If we had a sixth sense, we would perceive the world differently. The world may be existing in several dimensions or levels, but still the world is one. Other-Worldliness views the imperceptible part of the world as another world, but One-Worldliness does not see it as another world. This-Worldliness denies the existence of the imperceptible part, but One-Worldliness affirms its existence.  Thus One-Worldliness effectively resolves the issues of Other-Worldliness and This-Worldliness.

Now we  will see how the relationship between God, Man, and World is viewed in these three worldviews.

Man-World Relationship
In the Other-Worldly view, the world is like a container for human beings to exist. The physical world is a container  for our souls enveloped with bodies, and the spiritual world is a container just for our souls.

In the This-Worldly view, the world is a container as well as a set of objects we manipulate and exploit for our existence. Think of the lice that live on the body of a cow. Also they live by sucking its blood. Cow's body provides the lice not only a place to stay but also its food. Thus we are to the world like the lice are to a cow.

But in the One-Worldly view, human beings are seen as integral parts of the world. The human beings to the world are like cells or organs of a body. The whole world is seen as one organism. According to this view, the world is not just a container for people to exist. Nor is it like a cow the lice suck blood from. It is an extension of our body.  The world is seen as an integral whole in the original, Biblical view. This picture is clearly seen in the Psalm of Gen 1 where we read how God creates the world with human beings as its integral parts, and in Psalm 104 where we read how God manages the world with human beings as its part. Such a view of the world can be seen in the Stoic Philosophy (Greek) where the world is referred to as a macrocosm, that breathes together.

God-World Relationship
In the Other-Worldly view, God is like a king, and the world is like a kingdom. But God's will is fully done only in the spiritual world. In the physical world, God's will is only partially realized. 

In the This-Worldly view, God's existence is denied. God, along with the other world, is imperceptible, and so God doesn't exist.  The perceptible world is all that exists.

In the One-Worldly view, the world, which is within the limits of time and space, exists within God, who is infinite. From God's viewpoint, the world does not have a separate existence from God. The world depends for its existence upon God, it has no existence apart from God. The world is like the flame of a lamp that is lit forever using an endless source of energy.  The existence of the flame depends every moment on the energy supply. The world is related to God in a similar way.

God-Man Relationship
In the Other-Worldly view, God is the creator of human beings. God creates human  spiritual soul, covers it with a physical body, and places it in the physical world. Human beings are supposed to follow the will of God. At death the soul leaves the body and either enters heaven where God's presence is fully enjoyed, or enters hell where God's presence is not experienced. Entering heaven or hell depends on their following the will of God while in the physical world. People who do not follow the will of God have the opportunity to repent and start doing God's will while living in the physical world.

In the This-Worldly view, God doesn't exist, and so man is on his own.

In the One-Worldly view too, God is the creator of human beings, and they are supposed follow the will of God. Man (humanity) has a mediatorial role, representing the world before God and God before the world. Man is God's image for the rest of the creation, which makes man the visible representation of God for the world. Humanity as the microcosm represents the world, the macrocosm, before God. This makes man responsible and his existence is made purposeful.

 Conclusion
Thus I differ from an evangelical Christian in my view of the world. There are so many things in common for us. We both have faith in God, we have the same Bible, and we speak about salvation, gospel, righteousness, and other such key terms. However, because of our difference in our view of the world, we give different meanings to the key terms. For example, salvation is not the soul going to heaven in my view. It has a much wider sense. There is not another world for me to escape from this world and go there. There is only one world. The world was originally like a Garden of Eden, but we, human beings, have made a mess here. The solution is to fix the mess, not to escape to another world.  The mess has been created by broken relationships, and mess needs to be fixed by mending the broken relationships. The world becoming a Garden of Eden once again is salvation.

This is just one example of how I differ from an evangelical Christian. This difference is caused by the difference in the way we view the world. I don't have anything against the evangelical Christians, for they are normal, ordinary human beings like everybody else. I used to hold the same worldview as they hold when I was young. But as I grew older, I was fortunate to have a saner view. Evangelical Christians are not the only ones who hold this view. There are people in almost all the religious traditions who hold a similar worldview, only it finds expression very forcefully in the evangelical Christianity in today's world.

Monday, March 14, 2011

The Gospel of Evangelical Christianity

“Millions of people in this country whose lives have never been changed believe themselves born again because we have so reduced the gospel of Jesus Christ that it means nothing more than a simple decision that will only take five minutes of your time,” admits Paul Washer, an American evangelical missionary in Peru.
 
He explains the evangelical method of making people born again as follows:
“You walk up to someone and ask ‘Are you a sinner?’ If he says ‘yes’, then you ask, ‘Would you like to go to heaven?’ If he says ‘yes’, then you ask, ‘Would you like to ask Jesus to come into your heart?’ If he says ‘yes’, he prays that simple prayer. Then you ask him if he was sincere, and if he says ‘yes’ then you declare him to be born again. “
 
Paul Washer admits that the evangelical Christianity has done more harm than all the heresies combined by its simplistic method of making people born again. He asserts that the greatest need in the evangelical community today is that they need to know the gospel of Jesus Christ.
 
Paul Washer has given an excellent diagnosis of the illness of evangelical Christianity. He correctly assesses that the evangelical Christianity has become a show off without any real content. It has become a Christ-less Christianity. It does not serve its purpose anymore. It is a movement without power. Therefore, the evangelical Christian community needs to turn to Christ before it can help others to do so. It has to hear anew the gospel of Christ, and repent.
 
With this introduction, Paul Washer proceeds to a proclamation of Jesus’ Gospel as he understands it.  Although I fully agree with him in his analysis of the present state of evangelical Christianity, I cannot agree with him fully in his understanding of the Christian Gospel. In order to explain how I differ from him, I will present my own understanding here first, and then present his understanding.
 
The Gospel of Jesus Christ in my Understanding
Jesus’ Gospel is the good news of salvation for humankind, which is in the captivity of sin. Unlike the rest of the creation, humankind disobeys its creator. The Sun and moon, the earth and heaven, plants and animals—all of them obey the creator, but not human beings. We live a life according to our own will rather than according to the will of God. Not only that we are sinners, we don’t even know that we are sinners. Because we don’t see the glory of our creator, we don’t see the heinous nature of disobeying Him. Just as the fish in water do not know that they are wet, we don’t know that we are sinners.
 
This is the Christian diagnosis of the human condition. I don’t think any Christian tradition would disagree with this diagnosis. We, human beings, have to live our life according to the universal laws set by the creator. All of our problems in our life are caused by our disobedience. All our sciences and other branches of learning are our attempts to discover the universal laws. They all tell us that a healthy life depends upon the obedience of the natural laws set by the creator.
 
The Christian gospel is that this problem of humanity has a solution. It is possible for humanity to establish the right relationship with the creator so that they can live a life of obedience. Here is a short passage from John’s epistle, which clearly summarizes the Christian view of the problem and the solution.
 
God is light; in him there is no darkness at all. If we claim to have fellowship with him and yet walk in the darkness, we lie and do not live out the truth. But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus, his Son, purifies us from all sin.  If we claim to be without sin, we deceive ourselves and the truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just and will forgive us our sins and purify us from all unrighteousness.  If we claim we have not sinned, we make him out to be a liar and his word is not in us. I john 1: 5-10
 
According to John, the problem of the humanity is this: There exists an enmity between God and man. Why? God is light, but we live in darkness. Not only that we live in darkness, but also that we deny that we live in darkness. We can have a friendship (fellowship) with God only if we also live in light. The solution is simple: all that we have to do is to admit that we are in darkness, and come to the light. This is like a sick person admits that he is sick, and goes to the doctor. Once we establish friendship (fellowship) with God, we will also have friendship with each other. We will have a life of obedience. Like the rest of the creation, we will also live according to the will of God.
 
John also mentions that the blood of Jesus purifies us from all our sins. This statement implies that Jesus’ death on the cross was like a sin offering, one of the sacrifices in Jewish religion. In Jewish religion, they were supposed to sacrifice animals on the altar to pay off for their sins to God. The early Christianity understood Jesus’ death by relating it to a sacrifice-- the ultimate sacrifice which paid off all the sins of all humanity. However, in order for someone to establish the right relationship with God, he/she doesn’t need to know about this. All that a sick person needs to do is to admit that he is sick, and comes to the doctor; similarly all that we have to do is to admit that we are sinners, and come to God.
 
This is the essence of Jesus Christ’s gospel as I understand it. It correctly diagnoses the human problem, and prescribes a working solution. 
 
I used a passage from John’s epistle to explain this. I can also present a passage from Paul’s epistle to Romans. “But now apart from the law the righteousness of God has been made known, to which the Law and the Prophets testify.  This righteousness is given through faith in Jesus Christ to all who believe. There is no difference between Jew and Gentile, for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, and all are justified freely by his grace through the redemption that came by Christ Jesus.  God presented Christ as a sacrifice of atonement, through the shedding of his blood—to be received by faith” Rom. 3:21-25
 
Although we are sinners, we deny this, and remain self-righteous.  In order to be justified (establish fellowship with God), we need to replace our self-righteousness with God-righteousness. In other words, we need to agree that we are wrong and God is right. We need to have faith in God to do so. This is like a sick person approaching a doctor when he has faith in him. He also needs to admit that the doctor is right.
 
Paul also relates Jesus’ death to a sacrifice. “Faith in Jesus Christ” means faith that Jesus taught us or that Jesus exemplified. It does not mean faith in Jesus Christ as opposed to faith in God.
 
This passage is easier to understand in the light of John’s passage, but if we go to this passage straight, the ambiguous expressions such as faith in Christ and righteousness of God will be harder to deal with. The Christian exegetes have been wrestling with these expressions for two millennia to resolve the ambiguities.
 
There is a problem in the relationship between God and man, and this problem is caused by man. If man repents and reestablishes his lost relationship with God, it will solve the problem. This is how most of the Christian traditions understand it.

The Evangelical Version of the Gospel
Unfortunately, the evangelical Christianity built up a mountain of complicated set of beliefs and doctrines based on this passage of Paul.
 
Paul Washer presents the Gospel of Jesus Christ in his sermon as he understands it from his evangelical tradition. Using the passage from the Epistle to the Romans, he begins the diagnosis of the human problem as sin. He correctly defines it as disobeying God. The complication begins at this point. God is introduced as a righteous judge and man as a criminal standing in front of God awaiting the judgment. God pronounces capital punishment upon man—eternal death, which is life away from God in eternal hell. But justice is only one side of God; God has also another side—of love. When the justice of God pronounces punishment upon man, the love of God saves man from that punishment. How does the love of God do this? The love of God makes God (or the son of God) incarnate as a human being and accept the capital punishment from the justice of God upon himself. Jesus experienced a separation from God on the cross as a punishment.  Anyone who believes this will go to heaven after death, but to those who do not believe this awaits eternal hell.
 
I don’t know in whose brain originated this circumlocutory story. But this story occupies the central place in the creed of the evangelical Christianity. According to this story, the essential human problem is not our sin, but God’s wrath toward us. So primarily we have to deal with God’s wrath and not with our sin. How do we do this? There is only one way. We have to hide behind Jesus, because if we appear before God as we are, God’s wrath will consume us.  

By salvation the evangelicals mean going to heaven after death. When one's soul reaches the gate of heaven, the gatekeepers will look for his/her name in the Book of Life.  Unless his her name is found in the book, he/she can't enter heaven. No one's name is in the Book of life when he/she is born. Once he/she believes that Jesus died for his/her sins, and he/she accepts Jesus as his/her personal savior, his/her name gets written for the first time in the Book of life, which guarantees his/her entry to heaven.  They call themselves "the saved".
 
They give undue stress to the second coming of Jesus Christ. They believe that when Christ comes down from heaven, all the  "saved" people get to receive him in the mid-sky. The dead ones rise and the alive ones get transformed, and with a new transformed body they rise up to meet Jesus.
Because they focus on the other world, they ignore this world. They don't care for the world in which they live. Once they rise up in heaven, this world is going to be burned along with all the unsaved ones. Whenever there is a war somewhere or when there is an earthquake somewhere they rejoice, for they see it as a sign of Jesus' return.
 
Because they sharply divide people into saved and unsaved, they refuse to cooperate with the "unsaved" ones. They look down upon the "unsaved" ones who include not only the people of other religions but also those Christians who are non-evangelicals.
 
Conclusion
A good friend of mine forwarded the link of this sermon of Paul washer, and I took time to watch it. 
At the beginning, I found in this a wake-up call to evangelical Christianity which has come from within itself. I had a faint hope at the beginning that he might present the gospel of Christ in a sensible way. However, he disappointed me toward the end. He proclaimed the same corrupted evangelical version of gospel.  He argues that this is the true gospel of Jesus Christ, and he wants the evangelical Christian community to regain this powerful gospel.
 
Paul Washer needs to realize that the gospel he preaches is a version of the Christian gospel which was corrupted by the evangelical tradition. Its circumlocutory story is an insult to human intelligence. It won’t help anyone to be in right relationship with God, but it will only keep people away from God, for who can be in friendship with a wrathful God? He has realized that the evangelical Christian community is in need of the true gospel. But he hasn’t realized that he himself needs the true gospel. May God help him!

Paul Washer is a gifted person and I admire him for his oratorical skills and his courage to speak out what he believes to be true. Personally I have nothing against him. I am talking about him here as a representative of evangelical Christianity. Similarly I am not pointing finger at the evangelical Christianity representing some other form of Christianity. I do not represent any organized community or tradition here. These are my personal opinions.

For further reading: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8