How Jesus’ Message Was Replaced by Questions About His Identity

Immediately after Jesus’ death, the central question among his followers and critics was not What did Jesus teach? but rather Who was Jesus?

The gospels themselves show how frequently people pressed this question (Mark 8:27; John 10:24). They were not discussing his teachings about the kingdom; they were debating his identity. Was he the Messiah or not?

Once this debate began, Jesus’ actual message faded into the background. Very soon, almost no one was focused on the content of his teaching—the kingdom of God, the transformation of human life, the call to return to God. Instead, the urgent discussion was entirely about his status.

---

The Empty Tomb, Resurrection Faith, and Visions

According to early tradition (Mark 16:1–8; Matthew 28; Luke 24; John 20), Jesus’ tomb was found empty on the third day.
His disciples also reported visions of him:

• Mary Magdalene (John 20:11–18)
• Peter (Luke 24:34)
• The disciples collectively (John 20:19–29)
• More than five hundred believers (1 Corinthians 15:6)

These experiences convinced his followers that God had vindicated Jesus. In their worldview, only a true prophet or Messiah would be raised or exalted by God (cf. Acts 2:32–36).

Thus a significant number of Jesus’ followers concluded:

• Jesus was not merely a teacher of the kingdom.
• He was the long-awaited Mashiah.
• He would soon return “with the angels” to establish God’s reign (cf. Mark 8:38; 13:26; 1 Thessalonians 4:16–17).

This belief spread quickly and became the heart of the early movement.

---

Conflict With the Religious Leadership

The claim “Jesus is the Messiah” created deep tension with the religious authorities in Jerusalem.
Acts describes this conflict repeatedly:

• The apostles were arrested (Acts 4:1–3).
• They were forbidden to teach in Jesus’ name (Acts 4:18).
• Stephen was executed (Acts 7).
• A larger persecution broke out against the community (Acts 8:1–3).

From the viewpoint of the authorities:

• Jesus had been executed as a threat to public order (John 11:48–50).
• Claiming him to be the Messiah was dangerous.
• It risked provoking Rome and encouraging revolt.

Thus the early Jesus-movement was seen as a destabilizing group claiming that a crucified man was God’s chosen king.

---

Paul: From Persecutor to Apostle

Paul enters history in this context.

Acts reports that he actively persecuted the Jesus-followers (Acts 8:3; 9:1–2), acting—likely—with the approval of the high priest. He was a Pharisee, trained under Gamaliel (Acts 22:3), well-educated, deeply devoted to the law (Philippians 3:5–6).

But Paul also had an experience that he interpreted as a vision of the risen Jesus (1 Corinthians 9:1; 15:8). This encounter transformed him.

He joined the very group he had been trying to destroy and quickly became one of its most influential leaders.

---

Paul’s Gospel: Jesus Became Messiah Through the Cross

Paul’s letters reveal what he considered “the gospel”:

“We preach Christ crucified.”
—1 Corinthians 1:23

“The gospel… that Christ died for our sins, was buried, and was raised…”
—1 Corinthians 15:1–4

For Paul, the crucifixion was not merely Jesus’ death; it was the moment of enthronement:

• “He humbled himself to death on a cross. Therefore God highly exalted him…” (Philippians 2:8–9).
• Jesus is now “seated at God’s right hand” (Romans 8:34; Colossians 3:1).
• All powers and authorities have been subjected to him (1 Corinthians 15:25; Ephesians 1:20–22).

Paul proclaimed that the crucified Jesus had become the ruler of the world—the very role the Messiah was expected to assume.

Paul’s Message Addressed the Same Fear Jesus Addressed

People believed Satan ruled the world (2 Corinthians 4:4; Ephesians 2:2; 6:12).
Paul’s message was:

The new ruler is not Satan.
The new ruler is Jesus the Messiah.

This was, in a sense, parallel to Jesus’ central theme of God’s reign—but expressed through a different theological framework. Instead of calling people to realize God already reigns, Paul called them to trust that Jesus had now taken up that reign.

Thus:

• Jesus proclaimed the kingdom of God.
• Paul proclaimed the Messiah who now rules that kingdom.

Paul’s gospel was therefore connected to Jesus’ message, yet more complicated, shaped by resurrection faith and by expectations of the Messiah common in his time.

---

The Johannine Refinement and the Birth of Christian Theology

The Gospel of John (written several decades after Paul) further developed these ideas:

• Jesus was not only Messiah; he was the pre-existent Logos (John 1:1).
• His glorification occurred on the cross (John 12:23–33).
• Faith in Jesus became the decisive criterion for life (John 3:16–18).
• Jesus ruled with divine authority even during his earthly ministry (John 5:26–27).

John’s gospel did not merely say Jesus became Messiah at the resurrection; it said that from the beginning he existed with God.

This was a major theological leap.
It became the foundation of later Christianity.

---

Summary: How the Focus Shifted From Jesus’ Teaching to Jesus’ Status

1. Jesus announced God’s kingdom and called people to return to God.
2. After his death, the empty tomb and visions convinced his followers that he was the Messiah.
3. Debate shifted entirely to his identity—Was he the Christ?
4. Persecution strengthened group identity and accelerated theological development.
5. Paul proclaimed that Jesus became the Messiah through the cross and now ruled the world.
6. John’s gospel elevated this even further, presenting Jesus as the divine Word.
7. Christianity grew around these identity-claims rather than Jesus’ original teaching about God’s kingdom.